There are typically 3 types of testing – White Box, Gray Box, and Black Box. Each of these have their place in your arsenal, but it’s important to understand the difference.
The main difference between these three approaches lies in how much information the penetration tester has about the target system:
White Box Testing
- Information level: Complete access to internal systems, documentation, and source code. The tester is typically given a usable user account to test with.
- Simulates: An insider threat or attacker with extensive knowledge
- Advantages: Most thorough testing possible, can find deeply hidden vulnerabilities, given the level of access provided by the client.
- Best for: Identifying logical flaws, secure code reviews, and comprehensive security assessments
Gray Box Testing
- Information level: Partial knowledge (e.g., user-level credentials, network architecture). Not as much information is made available to the tester regarding the target.
- Simulates: A privileged user or someone who has gained limited access
- Advantages: Balances time efficiency with testing depth
- Best for: Testing specific components or finding privilege escalation vulnerabilities
Black Box Testing
- Information level: No prior knowledge, only public-facing information. The tester must discover the topology of accounts (i.e., fname.lname@company, etc..)
- Simulates: A real-world external attacker
- Advantages: Most realistic scenario, reveals what an actual attacker might exploit
- Best for: Testing external security posture and incident response capabilities
Each approach has its place in a comprehensive security program, with organizations often using a combination depending on their security maturity and specific needs. A well rounded security program will make use of each of these approaches at regular intervals. The key element for any type of testing is to mitigate the findings as quickly as possible, and retest to ensure they are truly closed.
One other thing….if I’m a bad guy, I’m absolutely going to offer these services (especially white box testing) to you for an absolutely ridiculously low price (or maybe even free).
© 2025, Think Like A Bad Guy. All rights reserved.